
Hotel Miramalfi
Best for travellers who want full-service Amalfi Coast facilities — restaurants, a sea-view gym, treatment rooms and a private Beach Club.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Miramalfi is a serviced five-star cliffside hotel in Amalfi with sea-view rooms, a private Beach Club and formal dining; read this if you want a full-service Amalfi Coast hotel with pools, a gym and on-site restaurants. Casa Mariantonia is a boutique guesthouse-style property in Anacapri with a very high guest rating; read this if you prefer a small, intimate Anacapri base for exploring Capri and nearby beaches.
Updated · about 13–15 km apart (Amalfi to Anacapri, typically reached by road/ferry)

Best for travellers who want full-service Amalfi Coast facilities — restaurants, a sea-view gym, treatment rooms and a private Beach Club.

Best for travellers after a small, highly rated guesthouse in Anacapri for easy access to Capri sights and a quiet, intimate stay.
When Hotel Miramalfi wins: choose Miramalfi if you want a larger, service-forward Amalfi hotel with multiple dining venues, a dramatic cliffside saltwater infinity pool and private Beach Club access.
When Casa Mariantonia wins: choose Casa Mariantonia if you prefer a very small, highly rated guesthouse in Anacapri — lower-key, rooms with garden/sea terraces, and a central location for Capri day trips.
Bottom line: Miramalfi is the full-service, five-star Amalfi option good for guests seeking on-site dining, wellness and beach-club access; Casa Mariantonia is the boutique, high-rated Anacapri pick for travelers who value intimacy and a compact local base.
| Category | Hotel Miramalfi | Casa Mariantonia |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Five-star cliffside design hotel with formal dining and resort services | Boutique guesthouse — intimate, nine individually decorated rooms |
| Location | Perched on a cliff above Amalfi, about 800 m (a ~10-minute walk) from Amalfi town centre | Centrally located in Anacapri on Via G. Orlandi, close to local sights and chairlift |
| Size | Approximately 35–40 rooms across four floors | 9 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome (kid-friendly; pets allowed on request) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools & beach access | Seasonal cliffside saltwater infinity pool and a private Beach Club with sea access (seasonal) | Seasonal outdoor pool and a hot tub; direct private beach access not listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues including Donna Emma La Cucina (fine dining), Azur Lounge Bar and Mario's Lounge Bar | One restaurant (Zagara) plus a poolside bar and a cafe/snack spot; complimentary buffet breakfast |
| Spa & fitness | Sea-view Technogym fitness centre, massage room and daily complimentary yoga | Not published |
| Known for | Cliffside views, private Beach Club and full-service Amalfi experience | Small size, high guest rating (9.6) and central Anacapri location |
| Transport & access | Complimentary shuttle to Amalfi town centre; narrow coastal road access | Airport transfer available for a surcharge; centrally walkable in Anacapri |
| Typical guest | Couples and families seeking resort facilities and dining options | Travelers seeking a quiet, intimate base in Anacapri or a small guesthouse experience |
Hotel Miramalfi sits on a cliff a short walk from Amalfi’s harbour and historic centre.
Choose Miramalfi for immediate access to Amalfi’s waterfront and a cliffside setting with private beach-club facilities.
Casa Mariantonia is centrally located in Anacapri on Via G. Orlandi with easy access to local sights.
Pick Casa Mariantonia if you want a compact base in the heart of Anacapri for exploring Capri and local sites.
Miramalfi offers a range of sea-view rooms and suites, many with private balconies or terraces.
Hotel Miramalfi suits guests who want multiple room categories with sea views and more on-site room options.
Casa Mariantonia has nine individually decorated guestrooms, several with terraces or garden/sea views.
Casa Mariantonia works well for travelers who prefer a small property where rooms feel personal and characterful.
Miramalfi runs several dining options from fine dining to bars with sea views.
Choose Miramalfi when you want varied on-site dining choices and a formal evening restaurant.
Casa Mariantonia offers Italian cuisine at Zagara plus a poolside bar and a cafe/snack option.
Casa Mariantonia suits travelers comfortable dining locally or at the single on-site restaurant for a quieter experience.
Hotel Miramalfi offers a dramatic cliffside saltwater infinity pool and a private Beach Club with sea access.
Miramalfi is the choice for guests prioritizing a distinctive cliffside pool and private beach-club access.
Casa Mariantonia has a seasonal outdoor pool and a hot tub for guest use.
Casa Mariantonia provides a small on-site pool and hot tub — fine for relaxing but not a beachfront resort setup.
Miramalfi provides a Fitness & Wellness area with treatment rooms and daily yoga.
Hotel Miramalfi suits guests looking for on-site fitness classes, a gym and a selection of spa treatments.
Casa Mariantonia’s supplier listing highlights on-site amenities but gives limited detail about a spa or fitness centre.
Choose Casa Mariantonia if you value a low-key stay and don’t require a full on-site spa or fitness programme.

Hotel Miramalfi — for guests who want restaurants, a gym, a spa treatment menu and private beach-club access.

Casa Mariantonia — for travelers who prefer a highly rated boutique guesthouse with personalized rooms.

Hotel Miramalfi — kid-friendly menus, cots and a pet policy make it a practical choice for families and pets.

Casa Mariantonia — central Anacapri location close to local sights and chairlift access for Mount Solaro.
Hotel Miramalfi — it has a private Beach Club with lift access and direct sea entry; Casa Mariantonia does not list private beach access.
Hotel Miramalfi — it is explicitly kid-friendly with kids' menus and cots available; Casa Mariantonia accepts all ages but is a small guesthouse.
Hotel Miramalfi offers on-site massage treatments and wellness services; Casa Mariantonia’s listing does not publish a dedicated on-site spa.
Casa Mariantonia — its Anacapri location is convenient for Capri excursions and local landmarks, while Miramalfi sits in Amalfi.
Explore how Hotel Miramalfi stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·